Abstract

Using standards established by Lovejoy et al. (l) to estimate age at death from auricular surface morphology, 266 individuals of documented age, sex, and ancestry from the Terry and Bass Donated Collections were scored. Analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) indicates that for the factors that could be controlled, age is the sole influence on auricular surface morphology. Ancestry and sex had no significant effect on auricular phase expression. No evidence of secular changes was detected when comparing the Terry Collection (early 20th century) to the Bass Collection (later 20th century). Pearson correlations reveal that several of the subcomponents of the auricular surface (superior and inferior demifaces, left and right sides, transverse organization, texture) correspond with age equally well, although a combined scoring of all features performs slightly better than any one indicator taken alone. Not surprisingly, only 33% of the sample was correctly aged when using the 5-year age ranges provided by Lovejoy et al. (l), suggesting that the published ranges are much too narrow to be used in forensic contexts. To assess the variation in age per phase, standard descriptive statistics and error ranges were calculated and can be employed by forensic anthropologists when estimating the age of an unidentified decedent. Because the mean ages of some of the eight phases did not differ significantly from one another, a modified six-phase system is presented. The auricular surface performs as well as any other single skeletal indicator of adultage. This research suggests that a statistically-informed approach should be taken in order to fully understand the drawbacks and limitations of any aging method.

References

1.
Lovejoy
CO
,
Meindl
R
,
Pryzbeck
TR
,
Mensforth
RP
.
Chronological metamorphosis of the auricular surface of the ilium: a new method for the determination of adult skeletal age at death
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1985
;
68
:
15
28
.
2.
Brooks
S
,
Suchey
JM
.
Skeletal age determination based on the os pubis: a comparison of the Acsadi-Nemeskeri and Suchey-Brooks methods
.
Human Evolution
1990
;
5
:
227
38
.
3.
Iscan
MY
,
Loth
S
,
Wright
RK
.
Age estimation from the rib by phase analysis: white males
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1984
;
29
:
1094
1104
.
4.
Iscan
MY
,
Loth
S
,
Wright
RK
.
Age estimation from the rib by phase analysis: white females
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1984
;
30
:
853
63
.
5.
Katz
D
,
Suchey
J
.
Age determination of the male os pubis
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1986
;
69
:
427
35
.
6.
Nawrocki
SP
Regression formulae for estimating age at death from cranial suture closure
. In:
Reichs
KJ
, editor.
Forensic osteology: advances in the identification of human remains
.
New York
:
Wiley-Liss
,
1998
;
276
92
.
7.
Buckberry
J
,
Chamberlain
AT
.
Age estimation from the auricular surface of the ilium: a revised method
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
2002
;
119
:
231
9
.
8.
Osborne
D
.
Reconsidering the auricular surface as an indicator of age at death [masters thesis in anthropology]
. Kalamazoo (MI):
Western Michigan University
,
2000
.
9.
Schmitt
A
,
Murail
P
,
Cunha
E
,
Rougeé
D
.
Variability of the pattern of aging on the human skeleton: evidence from bone indicators and implications on age at death estimation
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
2002
;
47
:
1
7
.
10.
Maples
WR
.
The practical application of age-estimation techniques
. In:
Iscan
MY
, editor.
Age markers in the human skeleton
.
Springfield
:
Charles C. Thomas
,
1989
;
319
24
.
11.
Nawrocki
SP
,
Osborne
DL
.
Serious problems in the estimation of age from human skeletal remains
.
Proceedings of the 7th Midwest Bioarcheology & Forensic Anthropology Association
,
Columbia, MO
2000
.
12.
Simmons
T
.
Revising age estimation standards for a Bosnian forensic population: clavicle, rib and pubic symphysis
.
Proceedings of the American Association of Physical Anthropology
.
Columbus, OH
1999
.
13.
Murray
KA
,
Murray
T
.
A test of the auricular surface aging technique
.
J Forensic Sci
 0022-1198
1991
;
36
:
1162
9
.
14.
Meindl
RS
,
Lovejoy
CO
.
Age changes in the pelvis: implications for paleodemography
. In:
Iscan
MY
, editor.
Age markers in the human skeleton
.
Springfield
:
Charles C. Thomas
,
1989
;
137
67
.
15.
Lovejoy
CO
,
Meindl
R
,
Mensforth
RP
,
Barton
TJ
.
Multifactorial determination of skeletal age at death: a method and blind tests of its accuracy
.
Am J Phys Anthropol
 0002-9483
1985
;
68
:
1
14
.
16.
Lovejoy
CO
,
Meindl
R
,
Tague
RG
,
Latimer
B
.
The senescent biology of the hominoid pelvis: its bearing on the pubic symphysis and auricular surface as age-at-death indicators in the human skeleton
.
Rivista di Antropologia (Roma)
1995
;
73
:
31
49
.
17.
Iscan
MY
.
Age markers in the human skeleton
.
Springfield
:
Charles C. Thomas
,
1989
.
18.
Thompson
D
.
Forensic anthropology
. In:
Spencer
F
, editor.
A history of American physical anthropology: 1930–1980
.
New York
:
Academic Press
,
1982
;
357
69
.
19.
SPSS for Windows. Release 9.0.5
.
Chicago
:
SPSS Inc.
1998
.
20.
Wilkinson
L
.
SYSTAT for the Macintosh. Version 5.2
.
Evanston
:
Systat Inc.
1992
.
21.
Daniel
WW
.
Biostatistics: a foundation for analysisin the health sciences
.
New York
:
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
,
1999
.
22.
Keppel
G
.
Design and analysis: a researcher's handbook
.
New Jersey
:
Prentice Hall
,
1991
.
23.
Hahn
GJ
,
Meeker
WQ
.
Statistical intervals: a guide for practitioners
.
New York
:
Wiley
,
1991
.
24.
Lagrou
M
.
A comparison of multiple age indicators in US and Bosnian skeletal samples [masters thesis in anthropology]
. Kalamazoo (MI):
Western Michigan University
,
2000
.
25.
Lagrou
MK
,
Simmons
T
.
Age indicators are population specific-caution! Proceedings of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences
.
Seattle, WA
2001
.
26.
Marks
J
.
Human biodiversity: genes, race, and history
.
New York
:
Aldine de Guyter
,
1995
.
27.
Smith
BH
.
Standards of human tooth formation and dental age assessment
. In:
Kelley
M
,
Larsen
C
, editors.
Advances in dental anthropology
.
New York
:
Wiley- Liss Inc.
,
1991
;
143
68
.
This content is only available via PDF.
You do not currently have access to this content.